Finding Truth In A Sea of Insanity

Here we are, nine games into this college football season and Mike Gundy has a better record than Bob Stoops.  Raise your hand if you predicted this before the season.  Anyone?  If you do have your hand up, I’m calling you a liar or a massive OSU homer.

I guess I still find it funny that a coach with one loss can be considered brilliant and “having a great year,” but a coach with two losses has suddenly lost his way.  Fans are fickle creatures, and the media only seems to add fuel to the fire.  

Maybe we’re all in need of a little perspective, and as they say in politics, a move to the middle.  A move away from the fringes of the fan bases who either view their coach as the second coming of Vince Lombardi or a no good bum who is slowly ruining their beloved football program all because a national title is out of reach. 

What some fans simply cannot grasp is the impact of players on coaches.  When a team loses or plays poorly, the coach takes the brunt of the criticism.  Does he deserve blame?  Absolutely.  But a coach’s job is to put his players in a position to succeed.  Then, it’s up to those players to execute as they’ve been taught.

Stoops' championships are quickly forgotten when the Sooners are struggling. (courtesy

Take the Sooners for example.  Is it Bob Stoops’ fault when Landry Jones can’t catch a snap that hits him in the hands?  Is Stoops on the hook for Jones’ overthrow of Kenny Stills on what could have been an easy six for Oklahoma?  Didn’t Stoops dial up the perfect fake field goal call?  Should James Hanna’s inability to catch a perfectly thrown football come back to Stoops?  Of the course the answer is no on all accounts.  I think sometimes we shy away from criticizing college athletes because they aren’t paid and these coaches are making millions.  I know these kids are playing their hearts out and I would never question their will to win.  But let’s remember, most of the coach’s job takes place Sunday through Friday, and when Saturday rolls around, it’s time for the players to do their job.

Two years ago Oklahoma offensive coordinator Kevin Wilson was the man behind one of the greatest offensive juggernauts in school history.  The Sooners put up 50 or more points in nine games and led the country in scoring offense.  Sam Bradford was number one in the nation in passing efficiency and OU scored touchdowns on 85-percent of its trips to the red zone. 

Has Kevin Wilson lost the ability to coach offense, or are his players simply not getting the job done? (courtesy

Was Kevin Wilson a genius two years ago who suddenly forgot how to coach?  It sounds that way if you listen to the Sooner Nation.  To some clad in crimson, Wilson is predictable, unimaginative, and washed up.  Yes, I agree Wilson could have shown some creativity down near the goal line in OU’s loss to Texas A&M.  But is it a bad play call to hand the ball to Demarco Murray inside the one yard line?  How many times has that play resulted in a touchdown for the Sooners?  It just so happens that this time around, the offensive line got no push and got blown off the ball by the Aggies defensive front.  Is that Wilson’s fault? 

I’m pleading for some perspective here, please.  When are fans going to wake up and realize, “You know what, maybe this team just isn’t as talented as we thought before the season started.”  DING! DING! DING!  Congratulations on entering the world of sanity!  

Gundy is enjoying one of his best seasons in Stillwater, his Cowboys are 8-1 and take on Texas this Saturday. (courtesy

Now that we’re all feeling liberated, maybe we can also admit that Oklahoma State has far more talent than anyone realized.  Mike Gundy is a very good football coach and he’s doing a fantastic job in Stillwater, but guess what?  His players are making plays at crucial moments of every ballgame.  Gundy and his staff have recruited well, and they’ve put their players in a position to win.  Right now, the Cowboys are executing better than the Sooners.  Brandon Weeden is already mature because he’s 83 years old (actually 27), but with every game, he’s growing up as a quarterback.  No Dez Bryant?  No big deal.  Justin Blackmon is filling his shoes rather nicely.  Kendall Hunter is the back he’s always been, and the unsung heroes of this OSU season are the big boys on the offensive line.  They’re creating space for Hunter and time for Weeden.  So is Gundy all of a sudden some kind of genius?  No, but his players are making him look like one.

Justin Gent forced a fumble in the last minute against Troy to preserve a 41-38 OSU victory.  With Texas A&M driving for the winning score, Shaun Lewis intercepted a pass to set up Dan Bailey’s game winning field goal.  Johnny Thomas returned a pick for a touchdown in the fourth quarter at K-State, a play that blew the game wide open and allowed the Pokes to earn another road win.  The right plays at the right time.  OSU is getting them, OU isn’t.

For a heavier dose of perspective, consider the fact that the Sooners and Cowboys can still play for a conference championship.  Both teams have the chance to end up in a BCS bowl.  No, it’s not a national title, but it’s still better than 95-percent of the programs in the country. 

Stoops and Gundy will accept the criticism and they will also deflect blame away from the players because that’s just the kind of men they are.  Both will admit they don’t do everything right.  Stoops desperately needs to find someone who can kick a 30-yard field goal, and he needs to find a way to inspire passion in his team when it leaves the confines of Memorial Stadium.  Gundy must find a way to keep his team improving on the defensive side of the ball, and turn this recent success into lasting success.  Both men are outstanding football coaches even if their stock seems to be heading in different directions.  So before we go thinking that a loss makes a coach an idiot and win makes a coach infallible, let’s realize that the truth is probably somewhere in the middle.