RDC Editorial: Whatever is Good, True & Beautiful

As acting editor of the Red Dirt Chronicles, I try to fly relatively under the radar when it comes to taking some sort of stance about issues in my community or in in our state through a written post.  That’s because this venue isn’t about waving the issues flag.  It’s about serving as an incubator for contributors who have a connection to the State of Oklahoma in order to highlight the regional culture.  The “Red Dirt” nuances that run through our veins, if you will.  In fact, I recently had a conversation with one of our contributors where he talked about a discussion in which he was involved; a discussion over the notions of that which is Good, True and Beautiful.  Those concepts, I believe, are like guidance beacons for what it is we do.  And while I’m certain that not all Red Dirt Culture is positive, shiny and includes a happy ending tagged on the end like a pretty bow, I assure you: our work will never intentionally be deployed to play up shock value or to harm those already hurting.

This was not the case last night, however, in a report filed during the 10:00 p.m. news hour by KFOR (Channel 4 in Oklahoma City).  The reporter was covering a story about the arrest of a man charged with possession of child pornography.  I watched as some of the usual sensationalizing tactics were deployed and considered changing the channel when the reporter proved to the audience that the alleged perpetrator’s neighbor’s didn’t want to make a statement on camera.  “Get the hell out of here!” was the caption while they rolled video documenting this attempt for a comment.

But I didn’t change the channel.  I kept watching.  And then, a frown came over my face and my brow became deeply furrowed.  I finished watching what I can only describe as a tabloid story, designed to turn a tragic situation into cheap supermarket headlines.  “This is our state,” I thought.  “And that news team just crossed the line.  That isn’t news.  That’s just…wrong.”  THEN, I turned off the television.

A feeling overcame me that I can only compare to the time when I was in grade school once when one of our neighbors ran up to me. It was summer around this time of year.  He had been shooting fireworks and wanted to show me something.  I raced to keep up with him while he took me to an area close to our picnic tables by the creek. “Look!” he said, watching my face eagerly for a reaction.  I looked to the ground and discovered a gruesome scene.  The kid had stuffed a turtle’s shell and mouth with Black Cats, then set them off.  I turned and ran, fighting nausea on my way back to safety in our house.  Two scenes played over and over in my mind: 1) the damage done to the poor turtle without regard for its welfare; and, 2) the look of anticipation on the kid’s face.  He couldn’t wait to observe my reaction, to see how I responded to the scene.  I don’t hate that kid for what he did to me…and certainly to the turtle, but I worry about why he did it.  And, I’m a different person for having experienced that situation.

However, I’m not a kid anymore.  And I’m assuming KFOR isn’t run by elementary children.  So instead of running away, I advanced.  I wrote a letter to the station expressing my outrage.  I re-read the letter this morning and can tell I was feeling emotional.  I reverted to a conversational style of text.  Normally, if I want to write an advocacy letter or a letter expressing my concern about something, I try to use professional language.  Not this time.  I just wrote.

I’m sharing a copy of that letter for you which will explain my concerns.  I would also like to encourage you to write the station if you feel similarly once you’ve read the letter.  Here it is:

Dear Channel 4: 

I’m writing to let you know that I believe you made a serious mistake on your story tonight in announcing the detail and different types of child pornography photos that were found.

It doesn’t matter that there was a “young Asian male laying on a bed in a Power Rangers t-shirt with an adult hand displaying the child’s genitals.” Then you announced, “some were too graphic to tell about.”

Really? So, it’s okay to bolster the shock value of your report by detailing the one with a hand and genitals, but maybe others showing children in various acts were too graphic?

I am a marriage and family therapist, have worked at the Care Centers where they investigate child abuse cases, been through the Interdisciplinary Training Program for Child Abuse and Neglect at the OUHSC, and have studied family policy for many years.

It is my firm belief that simply the fact that there were over 10,000 photos was enough to report.

I do NOT appreciate the extremely poor decisions put into the report tonight. I don’t know who those editors were, but those children have parents, and firing up more public outrage by detailing even one photo is not necessary. It was a terrible tragedy, the guy is going to pay severely. But the children and their families are going to pay much, much more and having this documented for them to repeat over and over subjects them to even more pain.

In my opinion, tonight, YOU were the perpetrator as well.


Kelly Roberts

If you would like to write a letter, here is the link to their contact screen.
As I think about this situation now, I am considering our RDC “test” of Good, True and Beautiful.  I feel glad to know that although our contributors to this site are very different people who cover the political spectrum from left to right, they all agree on the shared mission of making positive contributions.  This doesn’t mean we won’t have essays that might cover the tragic scope of humanity, but we will not sensationalize our work in order to crank up your reaction.
And, I wish you a day where some of what you do is guided by the notions of that which is Good, True and Beautiful as well.



5 thoughts on “RDC Editorial: Whatever is Good, True & Beautiful”

  1. Thank you, Kelly, for speaking up. When we moved to Oklahoma in 98, we joked about, but took joy in the fact that the 10 PM news show ran a story about unfed puppies. That never happened in DFW. There was too much “hard news” to share. Now, all of our stations are competing to be “live, local, and late breaking”, sharing the dirt, and it is not Red Dirt worthy. I began years ago to simply turn the news program on at 10:15 to watch only weather and sports, and it is still my method of choice, though I sometimes stray to 10:00 and am often disappointed in how our local stations handle themselves. We should all have the courage to be vocal, and to choose not to be sucked into the mud pit that is more gossip mill than news reporting.

    1. Jeff – thanks for your note. It’s interesting to hear the difference between a place that has so much for choices on what to air every night…makes sense…but puts our stations in a competition crunch. Your encouragement was nice to read – KR

  2. Kelly,
    Couldn’t agree more with your letter. Having worked in a newsroom for many years, I know this sensationalism goes on all the time. It’s a cheap ploy by producers, news directors, and reporters to tease people into watching then always making a story sound as bad and as shocking as possible. Sometimes reporters are obviously reaching but they’ll do it anyway and are often encouraged by management to do so. I really believe that if TV stations started telling more uplifting, compelling stories instead of the same old sex offender-meth lab-city corruption garbage, people might actually want to tune in. The story promotion is out of control too. These stations might as well come on the air and say, “You will be murdered, we’ll tell you when tonight at 10!” Sounds silly, but it’s coming to that I promise. What really bothers me is there are very few stations trying to set themselves apart with real, quality journalism. It’s the same regurgitated stuff from all 4 stations, and it goes on in every market in the country. Anyway, I’ll get off my soapbox! Thanks for taking a stand!

    1. Thanks for the “you will be murdered and we’ll tell you when” line. Totally made me smile. Also nice to hear an insider’s voice in agreement…you are greatly appreciated, Mr. Loeber…KR

Comments are closed.